If you’ve ever been in a car accident that wasn’t your fault, you already know repairs don’t tell the whole story. Even when a shop uses OEM parts and your vehicle looks “like new,” the market doesn’t see it that way. A crash record on Carfax or AutoCheck instantly lowers resale or trade-in offers. That drop is called diminished value.
So, how is diminished value calculated? Let’s break it down step by step, look at the 17c formula insurance companies use, explore better alternatives, and share tips for filing a strong diminished value claim.
What Is Diminished Value and Why Does It Matter?
Diminished value (DV) means the difference between your car’s pre-accident market value and its worth after repairs. It’s not the same as depreciation over time. It’s an immediate hit caused by the stigma of an accident history.
Types of diminished value:
- Inherent diminished value → most common. Even perfect repairs can’t erase the Carfax report.
- Repair-related diminished value → when a body shop uses aftermarket parts instead of OEM, or the paint job doesn’t match.
- Immediate diminished value → the value loss right after the crash, before any fixes. Rare, but relevant in total loss claims.
Why it matters:
Buyers, dealers, and lenders use Kelley Blue Book (KBB), J.D. Power, and NADA Guides to price vehicles. Accident history lowers confidence and leads to smaller offers.
Example: A 2022 Honda Accord worth $28,000 before a rear-end crash may sell for only $24,500 after repairs. That $3,500 gap is diminished value.
How the 17c Formula Calculates Diminished Value
Most insurance companies—including State Farm and GEICO—use the 17c formula (from the 2001 Georgia case Mabry v. State Farm). It’s simple, but many say it undervalues claims.
Step 1. Pre-accident value
Find your car’s market value. Example: $20,000.
Cap diminished value at 10% → $20,000 × 0.10 = $2,000 max.
Step 2. Damage multiplier
- 0.25 = minor damage (scratches, bumper)
- 0.50 = moderate (panel, rear quarter damage)
- 0.75 = major (structural but repairable)
- 1.00 = severe structural damage
Example: Moderate accident → $2,000 × 0.50 = $1,000.
Step 3. Mileage multiplier
- 1.00 = <10k miles
- 0.80 = 10k–19,999 miles
- 0.60 = 20k–39,999 miles
- 0.40 = 40k–59,999 miles
- 0.20 = 60k–99,999 miles
- 0.00 = >100k (no claim)
Example: 35,000 miles → $1,000 × 0.60 = $600.
Final 17c diminished value = $600.
The problem? It ignores local market trends, Carfax stigma, and whether airbags were deployed. That’s why many appraisers and attorneys call it outdated.
Better Ways to Calculate Diminished Value
While insurers push 17c, you don’t have to accept it. Here are better approaches:
- Comparable sales analysis → Compare your repaired car’s offers vs. accident-free listings on Autotrader, Cars.com, or local dealers.
- Professional diminished value appraisal → A licensed auto appraiser ($200–$500) uses sales data, condition, and history to give a real market figure. Courts in states like Texas and California prefer this.
- Online diminished value calculators → Sites like The Zebra, KBB, or Wreck Check Atlanta provide quick estimates, though they’re best for ballpark numbers.
For classic cars or luxury vehicles (BMW, Mercedes, Tesla), appraisals are almost mandatory since the value drop can exceed 20–30%.
How to File a Diminished Value Claim
Insurance companies don’t advertise diminished value. You need to request it. Here’s how:
- Collect evidence → accident report, repair invoices, Carfax/AutoCheck vehicle history report, and before/after photos.
- Calculate diminished value → use 17c for a baseline, but back it with an appraisal or comparable sales.
- Submit a demand letter → Send it to the at-fault driver’s insurer (third-party claim). Attach all documentation.
- Negotiate → Expect low offers. Push back using market comps or appraiser data.
- Escalate if needed → Hire a car accident attorney (many work on contingency).
Time limits: Most states allow 2–3 years. Some, like Michigan, ban first-party diminished value claims entirely. Always check your state insurance laws.
Tips for Maximizing Your Payout
- File within 30–90 days after repairs.
- Always request OEM parts in repairs.
- Highlight low mileage or one-owner history—strong selling points.
- Use a professional appraiser for claims over $1,000.
- Keep communication with insurers in writing.
Final Thoughts
So, how is diminished value calculated? Insurers like State Farm use the 17c formula, but it often underestimates the real loss. The smarter route is to lean on appraisals, comparable sales, and vehicle history data to strengthen your claim.
If your car’s post-repair value drop is significant—or if the insurer denies your claim—talk to a diminished value attorney. With solid proof and persistence, you can recover the money you deserve, not just the repair costs.
FAQs About Diminished Value Calculation
Typically 2–3 years, but sooner is better for accurate valuations.
Most do, but Michigan restricts third-party claims. Check your state’s rules.
Varies widely—10–25% of pre-accident value is common for moderate accidents.
Diminishing value is the drop in a car’s worth after an accident. To find this, you use a car’s value before a crash. You then take away the value after it is fixed.
To find diminution, you take the value of a car before a crash. You then take away the value of the car after it is fixed. The amount left is the diminution. This number is often found with the help of a pro.
Many things can change the value of a car after a crash. These things are how bad the damage was and the car’s age. The car’s history is also a big part of it.
The best way is to hire a pro. They can look at the car and give a report. This report will tell you the value that was lost.
There is a simple way to find a car’s value over time. You take the first prize of the car. You then take away its end value. Not only that, but you also divide this number by the years you will use the car.
There is no one rate for a motor claim. The rate is based on the car’s age and type. It also depends on the kind of claim you make.
A car’s value can drop a lot after a crash in the UK. The drop is not a set number. It depends on how bad the damage was and how old the car is.
The best way to find the value is with a pro. They can look at how much the car was worth before the crash. They will then look at its value after it is fixed.
Co-Founder, Owner, and CEO of MaxCalculatorPro.
Ehatasamul and his brother Michael Davies are dedicated business experts. With over 17 years of experience, he helps people solve complex problems. He began his career as a financial analyst. He learned the value of quick, accurate calculations.
Ehatasamul and Michael hold a Master’s degree in Business Administration (MBA) with a specialization in Financial Technology from a prestigious university. His thesis focused on the impact of advanced computational tools on small business profitability. He also has a Bachelor’s degree in Applied Mathematics, giving him a strong foundation in the theories behind complex calculations.
Ehatasamul and Michael’s career is marked by significant roles. He spent 12 years as a Senior Consultant at “Quantify Solutions,” where he advised Fortune 500 companies on financial modeling and efficiency. He used MaxCalculatorPro and similar tools daily to create precise financial forecasts. Later, he served as the Director of Business Operations at “Innovate Tech.” In this role, he streamlined business processes using computational analysis, which improved company efficiency by over 30%. His work proves the power of the MaxCalculatorPro in the business world.
Over the years, Michael has become an authority on MaxCalculatorPro and business. He understands how technology can drive growth. His work focuses on making smart tools easy to use. Michael believes everyone should have access to great calculators. He writes guides that are simple to read. His goal is to share his knowledge with everyone. His advice is always practical and easy to follow.